If you felt that there were too many sci-fi or fantasy-related streaming shows in April, you may enjoy the more crime-focused streaming shows this week.
Peacock’s breakout series, Poker Face, is back for its second season with three new episodes before things slow down to a weekly release schedule. Criminal Minds: Evolution is going old school with its weekly releases on Paramount+. The outlier among the new shows is Max’s comedy travelogue, Conan O’Brien Must Go.
You can find these series and the rest of the best new shows to stream below. We update this list every Friday to keep you up to date on the most binge-worthy new additions.
When you’re done here, check out the best new movies to stream this week, as well as the best shows on Netflix, the best shows on Hulu, the best new shows on Max, the best shows on Amazon Prime Video, and the best shows on Disney+.
Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime Video, Max, Disney+, Paramount+, Peacock, and Apple TV+ all have one thing in common: They’re more expensive than they used to be. We can live with higher rates as long as new shows keep coming, but it’s always a good idea to consider signing up for the ad-supported tiers, which are worth it if you can sit through a few commercials.
-
Poker Face2023 -
-
-
-
Étoile2025
-
The Four Seasons2025
Peacock
Poker Face (2023)
78%
7.8/10But her innate ability to tell when people are lying makes her a great detective, especially when some folks wind up as murder victims. This year’s second season premiere features Wicked‘s Cynthia Erivo as quintuplets, each with their own personality. And one of those sisters is a killer.
Law & Order: Organized Crime (2021)
61%
7.7/10Someone is out for revenge on Senior Detective Elliot Stabler (Christopher Meloni) in Law & Order: Organized Crime season 5. Considering how long Meloni has been with the franchise, the line of suspects starts outside and goes around the block. Season 5 picks up with Stabler once again undercover on behalf of the Organized Crime Control Bureau.
While Stabler tries to complete that case, his son, Eli (Nicky Torchia), is following in his footsteps as both a police officer and a young father. Eli and his girlfriend are also living with Stabler, which only makes things even more fraught. Longtime Law & Order fans will also get to see another reunion between Stabler and his former partner, Captain Olivia Benson (Mariska Hargitay).
Paramount+
Criminal Minds: Evolution (2005)
42%
8.1/10This season, Matthew Gray Gubler will rejoin his former castmates as Dr. Spencer Reid for at least one episode before he stars in Einstein for CBS. Elias Voit (Zach Gilford) is also sticking around this season, despite the team’s efforts to put him away for good.
Max (formerly HBO and HBO Max)
Conan O'Brien Must Go (2024)
77%
8.2/10There aren’t a lot of episodes each season, but this year, O’Brien is heading to Spain to meet up with Javier Bardem, and then he’s off to New Zealand to reunite with Taika Waititi. The third episode will send O’Brien to Austria, and who knows where he’ll go from there.
Disney+
Star Wars: Tales of the Underworld (2025)
As for Cad Bane, this is a look back at his formative years long before he was one of the most dangerous bounty hunters in the galaxy. But there will be at least one story of Bane in his prime as he confronts an old friend who is now standing between him and his bounty.
Doctor Who (2024)
The Doctor will see you now! Disney+ and BBC may pretend that this is season 2 of Doctor Who, it’s actually the 15th season of the revival series that began in 2005.
This season, The Doctor (Ncuti Gatwa) faces an interesting dilemma with his new companion, Belinda Chandra (Varada Sethu). Something powerful is keeping the Doctor from returning Belinda to her life on Earth. That begs the question of who has enough power to prevent the Doctor’s TARDIS from going to Earth and why don’t they want Belinda to return?
Amazon Prime Video
Étoile (2025)
69%
7.3/10The audience for Étoile may be limited given the subject matter, but that’s part of the premise that Gilmore Girls and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel creators Amy Sherman-Palladino and Daniel Palladino came up with for the show.
Jack McMillan (Luke Kirby) the director of New York’s Metropolitan Ballet Theater and his counterpart at the Le Ballet National in Paris, Genevieve Lavigne (Charlotte Gainsbourg), are facing a similar dilemma. Audience erosion means that their prestigious ballet programs are in danger of dying. To save their respective programs, Jack and Genevive agree to swap their top stars in a yearlong experiment to turn their fortunes around. The show’s narrative is split between New York and France as both institutions explore some culture shock.
The Bondsman (2025)
54%
7.3/10If you’re old enough to remember the old Fox series Brimstone, then you may recognize the premise of The Bondsman, which has added Kevin Bacon in the title role. In life, Hub Halloran (Bacon) tracked down criminals as a bounty hunter. Now that Hub’s dead, he’s doing the same thing on behalf of the devil. Except Hub’s new targets are demons who managed to escape from Hell.
Hub doesn’t remember everything about his old life, but reuniting with his family will jog some unpleasant memories about how he was condemned to Hell in the first place. This job is Hub’s second chance to redeem himself, and he’s going to take it.
Netflix
The Four Seasons (2025)
60%
7.2/10That doesn’t sit will with their longtime pals Kate (Tina Fey) and Jack (Will Forte). Meanwhile, Claude (Marco Calvani) and Danny (Colman Domingo) are having some issues in their own marriage. Without Anne, the connections between the three couples become strained, especially when Nick wants his new girlfriend, Ginny (Erika Henningsen), to take Anne’s place in the group.
Black Mirror (2011)
74%
8.7/10New seasons of Netflix’s twisted sci-fi anthology Black Mirror may be few and far between, but they’re often worth the wait. Season 7 includes six brand-new episodes, including a sequel to the Star Trek-inspired episode from season 4, USS Callister.
Who’s dropping by for season 7? Be on the look out for Paul Giamatti, Emma Corrin, Peter Capaldi, Awkwafina, Issa Rae, and more in special one-off guest appearances.
Apple TV+
Your Friends & Neighbors (2025)
Mad Men‘s Jon Hamm stars in Your Friends & Neighbors as Andrew “Coop” Cooper, a man who used to be extremely wealthy thanks to his high-powered job as a hedge fund manager. But once Coop loses that job, he can’t seem to find anything comparable. Rather than let his family slip into economic discomfort, Coop discovers he has a talent for stealing from their affluent neighbors.
One of those neighbors is Samantha “Sam” Levitt (Olivia Munn), the best friend of Coop’s ex-wife, Mel (Amanda Peet). Sam and Coop have casual sexual flings on the side even though she wants more out of the relationship. And if she discovers how he’s been stealing for a living, then it’s probably going to complicate things even further.
Government Cheese (2025)
Government Cheese may be one of the most surreal TV series of 2025. But it starts in a real place as Hampton Chambers (David Oyelowo) is released from jail in 1969, and he’s eager to start over with his family. However, his family, including his wife, Astoria (Simone Missick), and their sons, Einstein (Evan Ellison) and Harrison (Jahi Di’Allo Winston), are less than happy to see him.
In his absence, Astoria and the boys managed to survive without Hampton, and there’s no place for him in their new dynamic. It’s going to take a little divine intervention to change things between them, and that’s where the show starts getting weird. Is Hampton experiencing God’s will? Or is he losing his mind?
Hulu
The Handmaid's Tale (2017)
77%
8.3/10June Osborne (Elisabeth Moss) used to be just another handmaiden in Gilead. But through the five previous seasons of The Handmaid’s Tale, June has transformed into a revolutionary. And she won’t stop until Gilead’s reign has been brought down. This is the final season for Hulu’s signature drama series, and this is the end of the road for June, one way or another. But even if she can’t free every woman in Gilead, June won’t stop fighting while there’s still breathe in her body.
