
The thing that’s really horrifying about these pictures is Max’s prison haircut.
Brilliant!
OK, but this was lifted from that marvelous French movie: “My Life in Pink” (Ma Vie En Rose).
WOW!! Nicely told in words and pictures.
In general the world needs more people like
you – intuitive and bemused and well, real.
Ms. Modan…you’ve outdone yourself again. I just cracked up–my husband and I have had these very same arguments over and over again. In our case though, we received a cartful of gorgeous clothes–some were for a baby girl. I was happy to dress my 6 month old in these (what did he care?) but my husband (and more to the point, my mother in law)had a mini-heart attack. I gave in.
My almost-two year old has taken to strolling around the house with one his three year old sister’s pink or lavender handbags, and also has taken quite a shine to slipping into her pink garden clogs if he sees them lying around.
He is just big enough now to fit into his sister’s Cinderella dress. Happily, he has expressed no interest in it.
Love this story and the illustrations are so charming. The natural way that every one in the family interacted.
Thanks
What a wonderful story. A tiny “Ma Vie En Rose.”
Reminded me of when my four year old son proudly came out wearing his sister’s tutu, eagerly trying to impress our guests. When all the male guests reacted with scorn and derisive laughter my son picked up on the negative vibe and never donned the tutu again.
Another terrific visual column. I love reading these every month. Wish they were more frequent!
Dana and Rutu Modan did a brilliant job skewering the double standards about costume, gender identity, and social pressure. This story spoke to me directly: several years ago I asked permission to wear a kilt in
my family tartan to work one day. My female boss, who, along with her immediate female staff all routinely wore trousers (“slacks” are trousers), was embarrassed and spoke to me about the “conservatism”
of the company. This is the same conservatism I suppose that prevents women and minorities from ascending into upper corporate echelons. I felt it really was a matter of control, dominance, conformity and prejudice
as expressed in this story.
Thanks, Jeff
I’d like to know what Senator Craig thinks of this.
Being the target of much hate for being gay and for denying being gay or being a heterosexual idiot or a Republican, I am curious about his reaction
to this clever sociocomicstrip.
(Full disclosure: I’m not gay.)
I love it!!! Reminds me of an old skit on Sesame Street where one of the girls has to hide that she plays with a truck and one of the boys has to hide that he plays with a doll.
my 2 year old son is the character in this story. he loves dress up and barbie dolls and yesterday his sister even painted his nails a pretty glittery blue and lovingly applied eyeshadow on his lids! his favorite
princess is ariel and he has a baby boy doll which he takes care of and sleeps with everyday.
we just let him be as it is his way of expressing himself. also he sees his dad taking care of him and wants
to do the same when he plays with his doll. he wants to be like his pricess sister and play dress up too. he is as comfortable in a tutu as he is beating up his dad in his spiderman persona.
i think this
is a great strip for parents to realize a child’s world is not governed by pink and blue, girl stuff and boy stuff…it is us who need to be children again.
That’s great! I remember my sister-in-law saying woefully, as she watched her toddler playing in the “dress up” box at his grandma’s house, “He’s just like his big brother… always getting into his sister’s clothes.”
since there have been several articles of late in the press, we have been inundated with kids who cross dress, some who say they are in the wrong body. Several of these [we have a group for parents] will stop their
cross dressing with social ostracism particularly at school We know that a not small percentage of these will go on to homosexual partner choice. Of late we are seeing more and more kids who demand to continue
living as other than their biological sex. Forttuately there is a reasoned approach to hlep these kids as they near adolescence…[delaying puberty] so that they have the opportunity to really try out what
is called a “real life experience ” as the opposite sex and better decide with lots of guidance whether they want to continue toward sex change operations.
I wish we had as good a piece on
transexual kids…but people in our group are working on such. This is such a lovely piece…I agree it reminds of Ma Vie en Rose.
This was positively brilliant and oh, so funny! Thanks for letting all of us look and laugh at ourselves and the world we live in today. Isn’t it interesting how rigid those gender lines still remain regardless how progressive we all imagine ourselves to be?
What a beautifully told story! I keep wondering how it turns out further down the road.
Brava!! What a wonderful tale of handling the complicated pitfalls of early gender identity. Very thoughtful, and a great read! Oh, and thanks to the NYT for delivering it.
Lovely. My wife made both of our boys frilly tutus for Christmas a few years ago. They loved them. They would put them, fashion a gun out of any conveniently shaped piece of stick and run around shooting things — fairy assassins.
The kid would seem to be transgendered, not gay.
My cousin’s fiancee has a 5-yr-old son who also prefers to dress in a feminine way. His Crocs are purple, and overall, pink is his favorite color. We took him on an outing this weekend and at a toy store, his brother chose a tin fire truck; he chose a plush pink pony purse, complete with braided mane and ultra fluffy tail. He carried it proudly over his shoulder the rest of the day. He has told his mother many times over the past year or so that he thinks he’s really a girl. She, thank goodness, is enlightened enough to permit him to wear dresses whenever he wants, and to smile with other adults and shrug and say, “We’ll see what happens.” I’ll be printing this wonderful piece for her to see; I suspect she’ll love it as I have.
Does Max ever wish for longer hair? A softer ‘do’ might go better with the tutu! Best to all of you and, most especially, to him.
C’est magnifique!If only we as adults were willing to be so open minded as children often are. A kilt, sarong, or dhoti are all versions of a skirt that are worn by men as acceptable dress in many cultures.
I love the way this story unfolds!
One day when my son was in pre-school, he chose a pink tutu bathing suit to wear playing in the sprinkler on a hot day. This led to much breathless hilarity among the staff, but fortunately no derision. My son has grown into a kind, secure, and tolerant young man who marches comfortably to his own drummer and stands up for others (but loves to tweak them occasionally).
My nephew couldn’t wait to get to preschool every day so he could put on the skirt they had in the costume box. Once he got his picture in the preschool newsletter absolutely glowing in a bride gown. We (and his teachers) all just thought it was cute and funny. Even now as a first grader he likes his tiara.
As a former boy whose biggest thrill was to prance around the forest near my home weilding a magic wand (formed from a purple iris) and a magic cape (usually my jacket) commanding my fairy army, I applaud your wonderous story. Have you read Marci Riseman’s similar story:
Comments are no longer being accepted.